The cheapest sensible place to stay in New York usually isn’t Manhattan. It’s a hotel one or two subway stops across the river: Long Island City in Queens, Downtown Brooklyn, or Jersey City on the PATH train. All three put you within a short ride of Midtown or Lower Manhattan, and they tend to price below hotels in central Manhattan on the same dates.
But the nightly rate is only one of the numbers. Taxes, transit fares and the city’s short-term rental rules change the real cost of each base. This guide scores the four options on the numbers you can check, then gives a verdict.
The numbers that apply everywhere
Before comparing neighbourhoods, three facts shape every budget stay in the city (all checked November 2026):
- Subway fare: $3 per ride, with a free transfer within two hours. OMNY caps your spend at $35 per seven days from your first tap, on the same card or phone (MTA). MetroCards haven’t been sold since January 1, 2026.
- Hotel taxes in New York City: a 5.875% hotel room occupancy tax plus 8.875% sales tax, which comes to 14.75%, plus $2 per room per night (for rooms of $40 or more) and a $1.50 state unit fee (NYC Department of Finance HTX form; summary at Roommaster).
- Airbnb is mostly off the table. Under Local Law 18, you can’t rent a whole apartment for under 30 nights. Short stays are only legal with the host living in the unit, with at most two guests (amNY).
So a $200 room in New York City really costs about $233.50 a night ($200 + 14.75% + $2 + $1.50) before resort or facility fees. That’s our arithmetic from the rates above.
The scorecard
| Base | Transit into Manhattan | Fare per ride | Counts toward OMNY cap? | Tax regime | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Midtown / Times Square | Already there; most lines | $3 | Yes | NYC (14.75% + $3.50/night) | Convenient, rarely cheap |
| Long Island City, Queens | E, M, 7 and N/W, one or two stops | $3 | Yes | NYC | Best all-rounder |
| Downtown Brooklyn | Many lines (2/3, 4/5, A/C, R and more) | $3 | Yes | NYC | Best for Lower Manhattan |
| Jersey City | PATH to World Trade Center or 33rd St | $3.25 | No (separate system) | New Jersey | Best when NYC is sold out |
Fares: MTA; PATH fare rose to $3.25 on May 4, 2026 (6sqft).

Long Island City: the best all-round budget base
NYC Tourism calls LIC a former manufacturing hub turned into Queens’ artistic centre, and lists mid-range chains such as the SpringHill Suites and Wingate there alongside the Boro Hotel (NYC Tourism). The draw for budget travellers is geometry: Queens Plaza and Court Square sit right across the East River from Midtown, on several subway lines.
- Pick it if: you want Midtown sights (MoMA, Rockefeller Center, Central Park) on a NYC-taxed budget.
- Skip it if: your trip is mostly Lower Manhattan and Brooklyn. Downtown Brooklyn is better placed for that.
Our tip: Check exactly which station your hotel is near. A hotel by Court Square or Queens Plaza is far better connected than one a 15-minute walk inland.
Downtown Brooklyn: the best base for Lower Manhattan
NYC Tourism describes Downtown Brooklyn as a business district with “great transport access”, and lists hotels such as the Hilton Brooklyn, the Tillary and the New York Marriott at the Brooklyn Bridge (NYC Tourism). It’s one of the city’s busiest subway hubs, a short ride under the river to the Financial District, and a walk from the Brooklyn Bridge.
- Pick it if: you plan on the 9/11 Memorial, the Statue of Liberty ferry, the Brooklyn Bridge and DUMBO.
- Skip it if: you’ll spend most evenings in Midtown theatres.

Jersey City: cheapest on paper, with two catches
Jersey City sits across the Hudson from Lower Manhattan. PATH trains run to the World Trade Center and up Sixth Avenue to 33rd Street, and since May 2026 they run seven days a week on all four lines again (6sqft).
The catches:
- PATH doesn’t count toward the MTA’s $35 weekly cap. Every PATH ride is $3.25, rising by 25 cents each January to $4 by 2029. Two PATH trips a day for a week adds about $45 on top of your subway spending.
- You’re in a different state. New Jersey hotels charge New Jersey’s taxes, not New York’s. Compare the final total at checkout, not the headline rate.
Pick it if: you’re travelling on a big-event weekend when Manhattan and Queens rates spike. Skip it if: you’ll cross the river many times a day.
Midtown: when paying more is the budget choice
It sounds backwards, but Midtown can be the cheaper base for short stays. If you’re in the city for two nights and plan to be out from breakfast until midnight, the time saved on transfers is worth more than the difference in room rate. Look at the full price (including the 14.75% and $3.50 per night) against a Queens or Brooklyn hotel on the same dates.
The verdict
- Best value overall: Long Island City, one or two subway stops from Midtown on a $3 fare that counts toward the cap.
- Best for a downtown-heavy itinerary: Downtown Brooklyn.
- Best emergency option: Jersey City, when New York City is sold out or overpriced.
- Avoid: whole-apartment rentals under 30 nights. They’re illegal under Local Law 18, and a cancellation could leave you stranded.
Pair this with our first-timer’s USA guide for the rest of the Northeast, and set up My Travel Budget Template with the hotel tax lines included. Before you tap a foreign card on OMNY, read how to avoid travel money fees.
Want the next scored guide in your inbox? Join the TravelSpatial newsletter for one mapped itinerary a week.
Sources
- MTA: Subway and bus fares and Tap and ride, checked November 2026
- NYC Department of Finance: Hotel room occupancy tax return (2025)
- Roommaster: Hotel and lodging tax in New York City 2026 (combined rate summary)
- 6sqft: PATH fare hike takes effect, May 2026
- amNY: New short-term rental data, 2026 (Local Law 18)
- NYC Tourism: Long Island City and Downtown Brooklyn, checked November 2026
Photo credits
- Long Island City Skyline 2026 by Kidfly182, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
- Downtown Brooklyn New York July 2013 by King of Hearts, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
The infographic is original to TravelSpatial. Photos are used under the licences linked above.




