Pick Caye Caulker if you want a small, barefoot island you can walk end to end, cheaper beds, and a “Go Slow” pace. Pick Ambergris Caye (its town is San Pedro) if you want real beaches, more restaurants and resorts, and you don’t mind renting a golf cart to get around. Both are a short water-taxi ride from Belize City, and both put you minutes from the same reef.
Still on the fence? Answer the five questions below. Facts and fares were checked in November 2026.
The two islands side by side
| Caye Caulker | Ambergris Caye (San Pedro) | |
|---|---|---|
| Size | Small and narrow, split in two by “the Split” | Belize’s largest island, about 40 km long |
| Getting around | On foot or by bike | Golf cart (about US$50+ a day) or taxi |
| From Belize City by water taxi | About 45 min | About 1½ h |
| Tourist one-way water-taxi fare (San Pedro Belize Express) | BZ$45 (US$22.50) | BZ$65 (US$32.50) |
| Flights | Small municipal airstrip | John Greif II airport (SPR), about 15–20 min from Belize City |
| Beaches | Swimming off docks and at the Split; no classic white-sand beach | Proper sand, including Secret Beach on the west side |
| Bed prices (rough guide) | Budget about US$20–50, mid-range US$50–120 | Budget about US$50–100, mid-range US$100–250 |
| Vibe | Backpackers, couples, “Go Slow” | Families, resorts, restaurants, more nightlife |
Distances and getting around are from Thoroughly Travel’s Caye Caulker and San Pedro guides (November 2026). Fares are from the Belize Port Authority’s approved list as published by the San Pedro Sun, and accommodation ranges are approximate. The Belize dollar is fixed at 2 to 1 against the US dollar.

Question 1: Do you want to walk everywhere?
Yes → Caye Caulker. The main island is small and narrow. Thoroughly Travel says you don’t need a golf cart, and the official tourism board notes that the main ways to get around are on foot or by bike. The island’s motto, “Go Slow,” describes the pace well.
No, I’d rather ride → Ambergris. It’s the country’s largest island and runs about 40 km north to south. Hotels are spread out along it, so most visitors rent a golf cart, from roughly US$50 a day, to get between town, beaches and restaurants.

Question 2: Is a sandy beach non-negotiable?
Yes → Ambergris. The tourism board talks up its Caribbean beaches and warm white sand, and Secret Beach on the lagoon side is the island’s best-known swimming spot.
Not really → Caye Caulker. Here you swim off wooden docks or at the Split, the channel that divides the island. Hurricane Hattie partly created it in 1961. It’s the island’s social hub: a swim spot, a bar and the place to watch the sunset, all in one.
Question 3: What’s your nightly budget?
Under about US$50 → Caye Caulker. It has the deepest supply of hostels and simple guesthouses. US$100 or more → either, but Ambergris has far more resort-style choices. These ranges are rough guides compiled from travel guides, not official rates, so check live prices for your dates.
The water taxi is cheaper too. San Pedro Belize Express’s approved tourist fare is BZ$45 one way to Caye Caulker and BZ$65 to San Pedro. Caribbean Sprinter’s are BZ$59 and BZ$69. The Port Authority published these fares in 2023 and said no increase had been authorised. Treat them as the ceiling, and report overcharging to the Port Authority.
Question 4: Are you here for the reef?
It’s a draw. Both islands sit close to the Belize Barrier Reef. The famous snorkel stops, Hol Chan Marine Reserve and Shark Ray Alley, which the tourism board places about a mile south of the Hol Chan cut, are reachable from both. Snorkel tours run from both islands.
The one difference: San Pedro sits right next to Hol Chan, so boat rides from Ambergris are a little shorter.
Question 5: Who’s coming with you?
- Solo or backpacking: Caye Caulker. It’s social and walkable, and there’s a cheap bed down every sandy lane.
- Couple on a budget: Caye Caulker, with a day trip to San Pedro by water taxi (about 30 minutes between the islands).
- Family: Ambergris. It has more space, more pools and more restaurants, and the golf cart doubles as the kids’ favourite activity.
- Honeymoon or splurge: Ambergris, especially the quieter resorts north of town.
Can you do both?
Yes, and plenty of people do. Water taxis link Caye Caulker and San Pedro in about half an hour. A common split is two or three nights on Caye Caulker for the pace, then two on Ambergris for the beach. Coming from Mexico? Water taxis also run from Chetumal to San Pedro, which takes about 1½ hours.

Practical notes
- Cash and cards: US dollars are widely accepted. Prices are often quoted in BZ$, so check which currency you’re being charged in.
- Safety: the UK Foreign Office says tourists on Caye Caulker and in San Pedro are vulnerable to theft. Use ATMs in well-lit places, keep away from dark alleys at night, and only book water activities with licensed operators.
- Hurricane season runs from 1 June to 30 November.
- Fees on cards: our guide to avoiding travel money fees explains how to avoid paying twice for the exchange rate.
The short version
Go to Caye Caulker for a walkable island, cheap beds and the Split, about 45 minutes from Belize City for BZ$45. Go to Ambergris Caye for real beaches, resorts and a golf cart, about 1½ hours from Belize City for BZ$65, or fly in 15–20 minutes. The reef is the same from both. Short on time? Sleep on Caye Caulker and visit San Pedro for the day. Heading overland next? Our Isthmus Run backpacking route maps the line from Guatemala to Panama.
Want the next route in your inbox? Join the TravelSpatial newsletter for one mapped itinerary a week.
Sources
- Belize Port Authority approved water-taxi fares (San Pedro Sun, 13 April 2023), checked November 2026
- Thoroughly Travel: Caye Caulker and San Pedro, Ambergris Caye (distances, transfer times, golf carts; November 2026)
- Travel Belize: Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye (Belize Tourism Board)
- UK FCDO: Belize safety and security, checked November 2026
Photo credits
- Caye Caulker Belize aerial (20688990128) by dronepicr, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
- Caye Caulker, Belize – The Split by James Willamor, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
- Secret Beach Ambergris Caye, Belize, January 2022 – 01 by Chad Davis, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
The infographic is original to TravelSpatial. Photos are used under the licences linked above.





1 comment on “Caye Caulker or Ambergris Caye? Where to Stay in Belize’s Cayes”